The icon for 1Password for Safari doesn't follow convention and clashes with the other icons on Safari. Take a look at this screenshot using this community site as an example. The other icons on the Safari Toolbar (Noir, 1Blocker, Share) have sections that are transparent, and look pretty good against the page's theme-color. This oddity is even clearer on a new window, where the 1Password icon is noticeably darker than the others. 1Password Version: 8.7.0 (Beta) Extension Version: 2.3.1 OS Version: macOS 12.3.1

I know that this extension is basically a repacked version of the chrome extension but please update the icon to align with Apple design guidelines and make it a monochrome icon like the 1PW 7 extension does. (1PW7 on the left, 1PW for Safari on the right) I hope there are at least a few people left at 1Password that actually care about those details and willing to do things the way they are supposed to be done on a specific platform. Thank you

I know this is the world's tiniest complaint but I agree with the folks here. Just from a UI fit-and-finish perspective an icon update for the Safari extension could go a long way here.

Thank you both for championing this feature. Since I use 1Password frequently, I personally like the look of the icon, as it makes 1Password easy to locate among my other extensions. Additionally, I'm someone who tends to switch between browsers, so I find the visual consistency of the icon helpful when using 1Password in the browser across different browsers. Having said that, I can understand the appeal of having the icon match your other extension icons in Safari for a consistent and clean look. This remains an open item in our team's backlog and I've made sure that all your feedback has been heard by the team. -David

I also feel like the icon sticks out like a sore thumb, where the 1Password 7 icon looked great on Mac OS. Would love to see a return to a OS consistent icon for Safari on MacOS. Other Chromium browsers do show coloured icons so this ones suitable there, just not for Safari.

Add options to change 1Password for Safari's icon

58 Replies

jmanes
Occasional Contributor
5 months ago
Proper icon tonight, queen?
enriquedfa
New Contributor
5 months ago
Please for the love of god, update this AgileBits lol
jmanes
Occasional Contributor
10 months ago
Maybe Santa can bring us a proper Safari icon for Christmas this year? 🙏🏻
1P_Dave
Moderator
2 years ago
Deg

Thank you, I've passed your request along to the team as well. 🙂

-Dave
Deg
New Contributor
2 years ago
Requesting this as well! Please make a monochrome extension icon to better align with other extensions and the operating system.
TimG1P
Moderator
2 years ago
Hi joshuakaufman

I've gone ahead and merged your thread with this one to keep the conversation in the same place.

Your feedback is appreciated and has been shared with the team. Although I can't make any promises, this will be seen by the team and taken into consideration.

ref: dev/core/core#15064
joshuakaufman
New Contributor
2 years ago
Ah just found https://1password.community/discussion/128524/add-options-to-change-1password-for-safaris-icon/p1.
joshuakaufman
New Contributor
2 years ago
+1 on this request. Current toolbar icon look 🤮 in dark mode.
joshuakaufman
New Contributor
2 years ago
The 1Password Safari toolbar icon doesn't align with the style of other toolbar icons because it doesn't use an outline icon. However, looks okay in light mode because of its light background. However, it looks terrible in dark mode, as if this wasn't ever considered. Could we please get an outline icon for 1Password that matches the macOS Safari toolbar style?

1Password Version: 8.10.28
Extension Version: 2.21
OS Version: macOS 14.4.1
Browser: Safari
1P_Evon
1Password Team
2 years ago
On behalf of David, you're welcome jmanes.

Thank you for your continued patience and understanding, let us know if there's anything else we can assist you with.

-Evon