App icon design suggestion

MacLifeGR

I know its a bit early to worry about the icon design, but i am writing it down so i won't forget... ;-)

Personally i don't the transparent background with the original 1pass icon. It seems a little bit off the OS design philosophy imho.

So either i would keep the original 1pass icon and remove the transparent background (check shazam icon for example), or i would keep the transparent background and create a white 1pass icon.

Just my two cents. :-)

SergeyTheAgile

Thanks @MacLifeGR, it's never too early, it can be only too late :) I'll pass this feedback to designers.

hideftv

Definitely keep the transparency option.

DBrown

Perhaps we need a way to do both. :)

BiggishTuba558

I'd keep the transparent background but the tile icon should be 2D and stylised instead of 3D and full detailed

DBrown

Thanks for letting us know your preferences, all!

pbryanw

@BiggishTuba558: +1, keep the transparency, and my preference would be to make the 1Password icon slightly smaller and white in 2D.

cksg

IMHO: Keep transparency. Icon should look like the dropbox icon (top left in screenshot).

DBrown

Thanks again for letting us know your preferences, all!

Rangeball

I agree, a modern 1Password icon (per cksg's suggestion), and option to use transparent tile or not.

DBrown

:)